In reply to Brandon Kraft.

I understand where you are coming from.  And I would agree that at least in spirit the continued relaxing of fasting and abstinence rules have been counterproductive.  But I think Mr. Akin has a valid point from canon law's perspective.

In any event I doubt Mr. Akin would use the chicken broth (and neither would I).  But canon law is a fickle thing, and the intent behind the law is often surprising vs American fondness of literalism in law.  IMO, I think as a layman while I have my own opinion on the matter I would not go so far as to claim to interpret canon law for others.  That's why there are blogging lawyers like Dr. Edward Peters who can do such.

Have a happy Lent!